First change "Premiere Joomla/Mambo Template Club Professional quality designs."
to "Premiere Mambo and Joomla Template Club. Professional quality designs. New Joomla Templates every month".

Add 'Joomla Templates' to the keywords.

Mention 'Joomla Templates' on the homepage. Currently plenty of 'Joomlas' and a few 'Templates' but no 'Joomla Templates'.

Try Googling for 'Joomla Training'. You are near the top. Do the same for 'Joomla Templates'.

You'll be pushed to get first position with www.joomla-templates.com around.
How about $100 for second place ? 

Steve

I really don't think it's even possible for it to be a template issue.  Quite likely it's caused by content, meta tags, urls etc.  Already got a couple of folks sending me some good information so i'll be going through it and evaluating what I'm missing. Keep up the ideas!

Since i installed sf_advance in my site and start to have some litlle extra work putting tags in all content items my site jumped to googles 1st page and 1º in msn.com for the keyword i need.

External links from wigh pagerank is a good thing also, try to put your site in all joomla directories/top sites, and always put a link to your site wen writing in foruns, comments, etc.

its hard to understand SE, especially google, in my case i have shitty sites in top of me just because they are hosted in geocities, lycos, and a regional portal. google almost doesnt see the diference bettwen geocites.com and geocities.com/mysmallshittyesite

hope it helps..

Dear Andy,

Please apply these moves. Remember, there is no one answer, its many, many factos working on a cohesive manner.

You have a challenge, you design for the consumer base, but you need to address SEO + SEM points.

Meta Tags
1) Your title needs to address the appropriate key words you prefer. ( Bad title)
2) Witihin you Meta Tags, your keywords focus more on Mambo, than Joomla. Add more. (No exclamation points)
3) I became your customer from the MamboDev.com days. Please ask your existing customer base to change their footer notes that read www.mambodev.com  (Example: http://www.centrodeportivo.com ) You will be surprise how this will assist your backlinlk and that new link write: "Jambo Works Joomla Templates"
4) As mentioned above, this is not a template issue. You lack the fundamentals of SEO SEM
5) Place your web site at directory www.dmoz.org - This should eventually get you into Google's Directory
6) Your Post - Go back to your entries and fill in the descriptions and keywords.
7) REMOVE THIS FROM YOUR Meta and replace <meta name="title" content="Frontpage" />)
Look at your description = use PLURAL TERMS whenever possible

<meta name="description" content="High-quality custom Joomla!/Mambo templates,
the premier Mambo Template Club, training, professional development services and products." />

9) Keywords - From point #2 - Mucho Mambo - *** Nobodys searches Joomla with exclamation point, Remove "!"

<meta name="keywords" content="jamboworks, Joomla!, joomla, mambodev.com, template club, templates, template, mambo templates, custom mambo templates, custom mambo components, custom mambo modules, free mambo templates, mambo demo, templates demo, mambo skins, free download, mambo addons, download templates, portal, forum, weblinks, tips, tricks, help, PHP, MySQL, web development, graphic design, mambo, mambo open source, Mambo, Mambo Open Source, CMS, cms, MOS, mos, downloads, files, templates, news, modules, training, mambo training, joomla training, online training, developer training, user training" />

10) Slash in title does not help us the visitors, not to mention ithas no value from search perspective. OUT.
11) Open the Syndication Module on all pages.
12) Every page should have a different title. Never repeat your title or meta tags.
13) Focus on forum to assist your optimization.

Call me Geoffrey 203-746-7589

Isn't there an issue with Joomla! and SEO retruning 404 errors?
 

http://forum.joomla.org/index.php/topic,28301.0.html

I know how you feel, there are days, months even when I hate google 
The number one google result shows in google as having 457 links pointing towards it, in yahoo it shows 34,600 back links and has the keywords joomla templates in it's url. If I search your url it shows that you have 95 links pointing to you in google and yahoo shows 5,430, you need to get more back links preferably all one way but not too fast as google penalises you if you suddenly get a load of them and don't get them from anywhere like "link vault".

Andy,

If possible, this will benefit us all   -  Unique page description and keywords.

We are already filling in the page descriptions and keywords so thatit can work well withsearch module...

Why not let every page be unique and extend those descriptions and keywords into the Meta Tag for the page. Exactly like MS Frontpage functions.

The Truth - Every page has the same web site default maeta tags from global configuration.